The season's first Subway Series between the New York Yankees and New York Mets was unsurprisingly centered on one player: Juan Soto.
Soto, who left the Yankees for their crosstown rivals last offseason, definitely heard the boos and jeers in his highly anticipated return to the Bronx this past week. The $765 million Mets slugger struggled at the plate through three games against his former team, going 1-for-10 with just two runs, and there was a notable moment during Sunday night's rubber match when Soto made a decision that left fans totally baffled.
With the game tied 2–2 at the top of the eighth, Soto hit a groundout fielded by Yankees' D.J. LeMahieu, who then made a nifty throw from down on his knees to get the out.
However, a closer look at the video curiously shows that Soto didn't really hustle to first base after his hit—he was caught ball-watching and leisurely jogged for a few seconds before turning up the pace about a third of the way down the base path. Had Soto run hard out of the box, he may have been safe.
D.J. LeMahieu takes a hit away from Juan Soto!
— Yankees Videos (@snyyankees) May 19, 2025
(via @ESPN) pic.twitter.com/uYwvx8AZV1
MLB fans—many of whom were perhaps slightly bitter Yankees supporters—were quick to point out Soto's concerning lack of effort during a critical play late in the game.
Juan Soto misses the Yankees so much that he’s trying to help the Yankees win by not running out what should have been a hit 😭😭😭 pic.twitter.com/57l8FqmwpS
— Evil Empire (@octoberstanton) May 19, 2025
Enjoy ya 800 million dollar hustle https://t.co/mwx5jjAR0k
— 𝙽𝚘𝚡 (@DJLMelevatepls) May 19, 2025
I would be pissed if I was a Mets fan just saying 🤷🏻♂️ https://t.co/5b3UZKOHWW
— Tom (@J_Steinberger97) May 19, 2025
Here’s what he was thinking https://t.co/Rfsat4BOT7 pic.twitter.com/GR5ace2yyc
— King LJ 👑😈 (@KingLJStyles) May 19, 2025
Juan Soto : earns 765 million dollar contract
— DRU (@Bodmondru) May 19, 2025
Also Juan Soto : Doesn’t hustle out the box on a ground ball
Juan Soto legit got his money and stopped caring, he’s making 800 million dollars and has an OPS in the low .800’s. horrendous body language, doesn’t hustle and seems happier around his Yankees teammates. We got fleeced it’s ok to admit.
— Jake (@MetsRuinedMe) May 19, 2025
The Yankees would go on to win 8–2, and walk away with their first Subway Series victory of the year, taking two of three games in the Bronx.
More MLB on Sports Illustrated
This article was originally published on www.si.com as Juan Soto Roasted by Fans for Baffling Move During At Bat in Yankees-Mets.